Papas Pizza Pensacola Downtown

Discover Papas Pizza Pensacola Downtown, offering delicious NY-style pizza by the slice with a crispy crust, stromboli, and fresh toppings. Enjoy outdoor seating, friendly staff, and classic favorites like pepperoni pizza and Greek salad in a welcoming atmosphere.

Welcome to Papas Pizza Pensacola Downtown

Experience the finest dining

Papas Pizza Pensacola Downtown
Papas Pizza Pensacola Downtown
Papas Pizza Pensacola Downtown
Papas Pizza Pensacola Downtown

Papas Pizza Pensacola Downtown welcomes everyone to enjoy authentic NY-style pizza right in the heart of Pensacola. Located at 18 E Garden St, this spot serves delicious pizza by the slice, featuring a crispy crust that patrons rave about. The friendly employees contribute to a warm atmosphere that makes newcomers feel like regulars. Whether you indulge in a classic pepperoni pie or explore their tasty stromboli options, every bite bursts with flavor. Don't forget to check out their Greek salad for a refreshing side. This bustling eatery thrives on community and the joy of good food, making it a must-visit destination for locals and visitors alike.

Papas Pizza stands out with a variety of offerings that cater to different preferences. The menu features an impressive array of specialty pizzas, including the beloved pepperoni, as well as savory strombolis and stuffed pizzas. A notable highlight is the option for pizza by the slice, perfect for those on the go. For those looking for healthier choices, the Greek salad and antipasto salad provide fresh and tasty alternatives. Outdoor seating enhances the dining experience, allowing guests to enjoy their meals in the lively downtown vibe.

With an average price of $16.91, diners can enjoy a delicious feast without breaking the bank. Peak times draw in a crowd, particularly Fridays at 7 PM, when the restaurant reaches full capacity, making planning ahead a smart move for pizza lovers.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

18 E Garden St, Pensacola, FL 32502, United States

Phone

+1 850-285-0943

Social Media

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Papas Pizza Pensacola Downtown
Papas Pizza Pensacola Downtown
Papas Pizza Pensacola Downtown
Papas Pizza Pensacola Downtown

Papas Pizza Pensacola Downtown is not just a restaurant; it's a gathering place for the community. With its vibrant atmosphere and an impressive menu, it's a hub for pizza enthusiasts. The location at 18 E Garden St makes it easily accessible, contributing to its popularity. The restaurant takes pride in offering authentic New York-style pizza, known for its thin, crispy crust and generous toppings. Cooking each pizza to perfection is a priority, ensuring that every visitor leaves satisfied.

In addition to traditional pizzas, the menu includes creative calzones, strombolis, and even pasta dishes like spaghetti with meatballs or marinara, appealing to diverse tastes. Variety does not stop there; guests can opt for salads, making it a friendly option for both pizza lovers and those looking for lighter fare. Many patrons rave about the ability to grab a slice on the go, which works perfectly for busy lives.

What truly sets Papas apart is its commitment to community.

The friendly staff knows regular customers by name and creates a welcoming atmosphere for newcomers. Local events often bring people together here, creating a sense of belonging that resonates with the community spirit. On weekends, the restaurant buzzes with laughter and conversation, embodying the essence of Pensacola's vibrant culture. Knowing that Friday nights are the busiest, with a full house, it’s a testament to how much locals cherish their favorite pizzeria. Each meal served here is not just food; it’s a slice of hometown warmth, making it a cherished staple in this seaside city.

Papas Pizza Pensacola Downtown

Papas Pizza boasts a charming exterior that invites patrons in with the aroma of freshly baked pizza. The outdoor seating area provides a casual space for friends and families to gather and enjoy their meals al fresco. This setup perfectly complements the lively downtown Pensacola vibe. On a sunny day, the outdoor seating becomes a popular spot, filled with laughter and conversation as locals savor delicious slices while watching the world go by. This ambiance enhances the dining experience, making it more than just a meal but rather an opportunity to soak in the charm of the area.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • Sunday11 AM-10 PM
  • Monday11 AM-10 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM-10 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-10 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-10 PM
  • Friday11 AM-11 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-11 PM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

If you get your pizza from any nationwide franchise place instead of Papa's Pizza, do you even know anything about pizza? When you enter, staff are warm and inviting, while still being chill. Pizza by the slice any time is fabulous or if you got a crew or are a chunky kid like me get a 14" or 18" Celebrity Pizza, or take charge and Build Your Own. There are a few beers on tap, cuz you know, pizza & beer. They also have a few wines, in case you eat your pizza with your pinky up. Skip that corporate doo and get this slice in your belly.

D
Dee T.

I called ahead for our pizza just incase. Everything about this place was great, the customer service really stood out to us. Super friendly staff that made you feel like family. They kept calling me by my first name when serving us. The pizza of course was awesome, as well as the beer on tap. Very happy, they also had the Christmas decor up and music playing.

C
Charles D.

Hubby and I grabbed a pizza here and were blown away. The service was fast and friendly with a chill atmosphere. The food was phenomenal; they crafted the perfect NY style pie. We will be back for more!

T
Tiffany S.

Every town has one great pizza place that people talk about. There are several in Pensacola, but this in my opinion is one of the best. I know for a fact that this establishment uses only the best ingredients in their pizzas. I actually met with the founder of these pizzerias years ago, and he told me about the ingredients that he used, and that they were top shelf, absolutely the best. My pizza had a phenomenal crispy bottom it was cooked perfectly and tasted outstanding! I have had many pizzas over the years, and actually pizza is one of my favorite foods. If you haven't been to this pizzeria, you owe it to yourself to stop in. Do not confuse it with any other pizzeria with the same name. This establishment on Garden Street stands alone, and this review is only for this location.

l
leonard n.

This is authentic NY style pizza, hands down. Passed the crust test, perfect thickness and taste. Best pizza in Pensacola. Reminds me of pizza joints back home in Philly. Service was phenomenal. Will DEFINITELY be back!

R
Richard P.

I'm a big fan of pizza, and Pensacola is a dead zone for good pizza... until I found Papa's Pizza. If you like a solid NY-style pizza, this is the spot! I always request it well-done, and they nail the perfect crisp, every time! This is easily the best pizza in Pensacola! I've heard folks say Sky Pizza, but they're crust is too floppy. And Graffiti is more for a drunken night. If you're looking for a solid pizza all-around, Papa's pizza is it! The ONLY downfall I have to say... is the price. Just be ready for your wallet to take a hit. $26 for an 18" is insane. It's more of a monthly treat pizza, rather than a weekly hit-up spot, solely because of the price.

G
Gregg M.